Open Source Twitter rivals to be a success?

Do identi.ca and Jisko have the open source answer to Twitter's problems?


Technology trends and news by Josh Chandler
August 11, 2008 | Comments (1)

6925

With the constant stream of Twitter "rivals" moving into the Web 2.0 space, it seems odd that companies such as Identi.ca or Jisko.net want to rival Twitter in an "open source" fashion. I would be really interested to see just how transparent they make this system with its open source features. Of course, if Twitter had gotten its act together on things I am sure we would have seen a open source Twitter come along.

A Techcrunch article called identi.ca's open source platform, as a way of "distributing the load" of the service to other servers. Evan Prodromou, developer at identi.ca, also made the point that Twitter would have also improved uptime and scalibility if it had been "decentralized." Many people wrote about this concept of a decentralized Twitter. My favorite is the post by Andrew Baron of Rocketboom. He even suggested that people should start using the microblogging service Tumblr to help spread the load of conversations.

One commenter on the blog post said "cross-posting to Facebook/Jaiku/etc. is pretty much distributed micro-blogging." I am constantly frustrated with this idea that people would spread the conversation to Facebook. Its appeal as a social network is far greater than its conversational aspect.

I would much rather throw a sheep at someone, than to discuss something with them. The only benefit of reaching out to Facebook is the increased traffic. But of course many of you will know Facebook has its own "status updates" facility built in. So this idea of updating Facebook via Twitter is completely redundant.

But how does open source hold up in a microblogging world, some reckons that social media microblogging will only mature when open source microblogging gains more popularity. In some respects does the Twitter API count as someway to be "open source", many applications such as Twhirl, Twitterfic, Friendfeed uses the API, but just how much further is Twitter willing to push the boat out, will it go as far as open source?

With identi.ca and Jisko.net opening up the open source platforms to new levels, I think we will see Twitter maybe extend it's API into open source form, but maybe just maybe they will need to address the matter of uptime first:

http://joshchandlerblog.blogspot.com/2008/05/why-does-twitter-have-so-much-downtime.html

(Note: Republished to feature on VatorNews homepage)


Related companies, investors and entrepreneurs

Thumb_3786_twitter
Twitter
Startup/Business
(5 ratings)
2764 views
Description: Where did the idea for Twitter come from? Jack Dorsey had grown interested in the simple idea of being able to know what his friends w...

Related news


1 comment

Submit yours
Jeff McNeill
Jeff McNeill, 99 days ago
The relevance and possibilities of open source to twitter is interesting because it has more to do with the larger open source and/or/vs. cloud computing. Twitter's ongoing challenges are cloud challenges (how can it scale) instead of open source (although if twitter code were open sourced it may get enough eyeballs looking at it and contributing code to solve at least the current scaling issues). The idea of decentralizing the load through open source and federations, a la XMPP and IM gateways is interesting, but it seems to be part of a larger set of issues such as data portability, openid, etc. Good post, thanks for moving this conversation forward. I don't think anyone has a clear concept for how all of this is going to work out.

Login to reply Jeff


Vator.tv top stories

Four kinds of work, and how to get them done

2008-11-17-four-kinds-of-work-and-how-to-get-them-done

From entrepreneur

by Eric Ries
November 17, 2008
Identify work; create the right team; allocate resources behind them

What am I Missy? Episode 2

4890_missyminute

Technology trends and news

by Meliza Solan
November 16, 2008
Disappearing startups, Al Gore's speech, and a thought from Zuckerberg

Ignorance and bliss

2008-11-01-ignorance-and-bliss

From entrepreneur

by Demian Entrekin
November 1, 2008
How much knowledge is too much?

Former MTV celeb Adam Curry on the new Mevio

4766_adamcurry_interview

Entrepreneur interview

by Bambi Francisco
October 30, 2008
Curry talks about new media programming and whether the ad downturn is affecting his company

Tough Calls

2008-10-30-tough-calls

From entrepreneur

by Demian Entrekin
October 30, 2008
How do we see through the fog?

Why a focus on profits is critical

3257_hi-5-lesson---08-10

From entrepreneur

by Bambi Francisco
October 19, 2008
Hi5 CEO Ramu Yalamanchi made money with seed round

Yahoo CEO Jerry Yang resigns

2008-11-17-yahoo-ceo-jerry-yang-resigns

Technology trends and news

by Bambi Francisco
November 17, 2008
Troubled online portal in search for new leader

Yahoo CEO Jerry Yang resigns

2008-11-17-yahoo-ceo-jerry-yang-resigns

Technology trends and news

by Bambi Francisco
November 17, 2008
Troubled online portal in search for new leader
© 2008 Vator, Inc.